Jane Ellen Stevens

The Adverse Childhood Experiences Study — the largest, most important public health study you never heard of — began in an obesity clinic

Mentions of the ACE Study – the CDC’s Adverse Childhood Experiences Study — have shown up in the New York Times, This American Life, and Salon.com recently. In the last year, it’s become a buzzword in social services, public health, education, juvenile justice, mental health, pediatrics, criminal justice and even business. Many people say that just as everyone should be aware of her or his cholesterol score, so should everyone know her or his ACE score. But what is this study? And why is it so important to, well, almost everyone in 2012, the same way polio became important to almost everyone in the 1950s? Here’s the backstory.

The ACE Study – probably the most important public health study you never heard of – had its origins in an obesity clinic on a quiet street in San Diego.

It was 1985, and Dr. Vincent Felitti was mystified. The physician, chief of Kaiser Permanente’s revolutionary Department of Preventive Medicine in San Diego, CA, couldn’t figure out why, each year for the last five

years, more than half of the people in his obesity clinic dropped out. Although people who wanted to shed as little as 30 pounds could participate, the clinic was designed for people who were 100 to 600 pounds overweight.

Felitti cut an imposing, yet dashing, figure. Tall, straight-backed, not a silver hair out of place, penetrating eyes, he was a doctor whom patients trusted implicitly, spoke of reverentially and rarely called by his first name. The preventive medicine department he created had become an international beacon for efficient and compassionate care. Every year, more than 50,000 people were screened for diseases that tests and machines could pick up before symptoms appeared. It was the largest medical evaluation site in the world. It was reducing health care costs before reducing health care costs was cool.

Dr. Vincent Felitti

But the 50-percent dropout rate in the obesity clinic that Felitti started in 1980 was driving him crazy. A cursory review of all the dropouts’ records astonished him — they’d all been losing weight when they left the program, not gaining. That made no sense whatsoever. Why would people who were 300 pounds overweight lose 100 pounds, and then drop out when they were on a roll?

The situation “was ruining my attempts to build a successful program,” he recalls, and in typical Type-A fashion, he was determined to find out why.

The mystery turned into a 25-year quest involving researchers from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and more than 17,000 members of Kaiser Permanente’s San Diego care program. It would reveal that adverse experiences in childhood were very common, even in the white middle-class, and that these experiences are linked to every major chronic illness and social problem that the United States grapples with – and spends billions of dollars on.

But in 1985, all that Felitti knew was that the obesity clinic had a serious problem. He decided to dig deep into the dropouts’ medical records. This revealed a couple of surprises: All the dropouts had been born at a normal weight. They didn’t gain weight slowly over several years.

“I had assumed that people who were 400, 500, 600 pounds would be getting heavier and heavier year after year. In 2,000 people, I did not see it once,” says Felitti. When they gained weight, it was abrupt and then they stabilized. If they lost weight, they regained all of it or more over a very short time.

But this knowledge brought him no closer to solving the mystery. So, he decided to do face-to-face interviews with a couple hundred of the dropouts. He used a standard set of questions for everyone. For weeks, nothing unusual came of the inquiries. No revelations. No clues.

The turning point in Felitti’s quest came by accident. The physician was running through yet another series of questions with yet another obesity program patient: How much did you weigh when you were born? How much did you weigh when you started first grade? How much did you weigh when you entered high school? How old were you when you became sexually active? How old were you when you married?

“I misspoke,” he recalls, probably out of discomfort in asking about when she became sexually active – although physicians are given plenty of training in examining body parts without hesitation, they’re given little support in talking about what patients do with some of those body parts. “Instead of asking, “How old were you when you were first sexually active,” I asked, “How much did you weigh when you were first sexually active?’ The patient, a woman, answered, ‘Forty pounds.’”

He didn’t understand what he was hearing. He misspoke the question again. She gave the same answer, burst into tears and added, “It was when I was four years old, with my father.”

He suddenly realized what he had asked.

“I remembered thinking, ‘This is only the second incest case I’ve had in 23 years of practice’,” Felitti recalls. “I didn’t know what to do with the information. About 10 days later, I ran into the same thing. It was very disturbing. Every other person was providing information about childhood sexual abuse. I thought, ‘This can’t be true. People would know if that were true. Someone would have told me in medical school.’ ”

Worried that he was injecting some unconscious bias into the questioning, he asked five of his colleagues to interview the next 100 patients in the weight program. “They turned up the same things,” he says.

Of the 286 people whom Felitti and his colleagues interviewed, most had been sexually abused as children. As startling as this was, it turned out to be less significant than another piece of the puzzle that dropped into place during an interview with a woman who had been raped when she was 23 years old. In the year after the attack, she told Felitti that she’d gained 105 pounds.

“As she was thanking me for asking the question,” says Felitti, “she looks down at the carpet, and mutters, ‘Overweight is overlooked, and that’s the way I need to be.’”

During that encounter, a realization struck Felitti. It’s a significant detail that many physicians, psychologists, public health experts and policymakers haven’t yet grasped: The obese people that Felitti was interviewing were 100, 200, 300, 400 overweight, but they didn’t see their weight as a problem. To them, eating was a fix, a solution. (There’s a reason an IV drug user calls a dose a “fix”.)

One way it was a solution is that it made them feel better. Eating soothed their anxiety, fear, anger or depression – it worked like alcohol or tobacco or methamphetamines. Not eating increased their anxiety, depression, and fear to levels that were intolerable.

The other way it helped was that, for many people, just being obese solved a problem. In the case of the woman who’d been raped, she felt as if she were invisible to men. In the case of a man who’d been beaten up when he was a skinny kid, being fat kept him safe, because when he gained a lot of weight, nobody bothered him. In the case of another woman — whose father told her while he was raping her when she was 7 years old that the only reason he wasn’t doing the same to her 9-year-old sister was because she was fat — being obese protected her. Losing weight increased their anxiety, depression, and fear to levels that were intolerable.

For some people, both motivations were in play.

Felitti didn’t know this at the time, but this was the more important result — the mind-shift, the new meme that would begin spreading far beyond a weight clinic in San Diego. It would provide more understanding about the lives of hundreds of millions of people around the world who use biochemical coping methods – such as alcohol, marijuana, food, sex, tobacco, violence, work, methamphetamines, thrill sports – to escape intense fear, anxiety, depression, anger.

Public health experts, social service workers, educators, therapists and policy makers commonly regard addiction as a problem. Some, however, are beginning to grasp that turning to drugs is a normal response to serious childhood trauma, and that telling people who smoke or overeat or overwork that these are bad for them and that they should stop doesn’t register when those approaches provide a temporary, but gratifying solution.

Ella Herman was one of the people who participated in the obesity clinic, but had dropped out because any weight she lost, she regained. Herman owned a successful childcare center in San Diego. Herman said she was sexually abused by two uncles and a school bus driver; the first time occurred when she was four years old. She married a man who abused her repeatedly and tried to kill her. With the help of her family, she fled with her children to San Diego, where she later remarried.

“I imagine I’ve lost 100 pounds about six times,” she recalled. “And gained it back.” Every time she lost weight and a man commented on her beauty, she became terrified and began eating. But she never understood the connection until she attended a meeting at which Felitti talked about what he’d learned from patients. At this time, Herman was just over five feet tall and weighed nearly 300 pounds. “He had a room full of people,” she said. “The more he talked the more I cried, because he was touching every aspect of my life. Somebody in the world understands, I thought.”

Herman later sent a letter to Felitti. “I want to thank you for caring enough about people to read all those charts and finding out what happens to all of us who are molested, raped and abused in childhood,” she wrote. “…I suffered for years. The pain became so great I was thinking of jumping off the San Diego Bay Bridge….How many people may have taken their life because they had no program to turn to? How many lives can be saved by this program?”

What do you do when you’ve got something important to tell the world, but the world thinks it’s stupid?

So, if you were Vincent Felitti, whom would you pick as your first audience to reveal your stunning findings? A group relatively informed about obesity that would greet the new information with extreme interest, praise and applause? Natch. So, in 1990, Felitti flew to Atlanta to give a speech to the members – many of them psychologists and psychiatrists — of the North American Association for the Study of Obesity. The audience listened quietly and politely. When he finished, one of the experts stood up and blasted him. “He told me I was naïve to believe my patients, that it was commonly understood by those more familiar with such matters that these patient statements were fabrications to provide a cover explanation for failed lives!”

At dinner, Dr. David Williamson, an epidemiologist from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, sat next to the perplexed Felitti. Williamson was intrigued. He leaned over and “told me that people could always find fault with a study of a couple of hundred people,” says Felitti, “but not if there were thousands, and from a general population, not a subset like an obesity program. I turned to him and said, ‘That’s not a problem.’ ”

Williamson invited Felitti to meet with a small group of researchers at the Centers for Disease Control. Dr. Robert Anda, a medical epidemiologist was among them. If Felitti is the model for a TV show featuring a wise and stately chief physician who sits straight, stands straight, and keeps his personal feelings in check, Anda would be the dashing, young, brilliant researcher who wears his tie askew, slumps in chairs, laughs easily, loves to joke around, and puts his heart on his sleeve for all to see.

Anda began his career as a physician, but became intrigued with epidemiology and public health. When he met Felitti, he had been studying how depression and feelings of hopelessness affect coronary heart disease. He noticed that depression and hopelessness weren’t random. “I became interested in going deeper, because I thought that there must be something beneath the behaviors that were generating them,” says Anda.

Kaiser Permanente in San Diego was a perfect place to do a mega-study. More than 50,000 members came through the department each year, for a comprehensive medical evaluation. Every person who came through the Department of Preventive Medicine filled out a detailed biopsychosocial (biomedical, psychological, social) medical questionnaire prior to undergoing a complete physical examination and extensive laboratory tests. It would be easy to add another set of questions. In two waves, Felitti and Anda asked 26,000 people who came through the department “if they would be interested in helping us understand how childhood events might affect adult health,” says Felitti. Of those, 17,421 agreed.

Before they added the new trauma-oriented questions, Anda spent a year pouring through the research literature to learn about childhood trauma, and focused on the eight major types that patients had mentioned so often in Felitti’s original study and whose individual consequences had been studied by other researchers. These eight included three types of abuse — sexual, verbal and physical. And five types of family dysfunction — a parent who’s mentally ill or alcoholic, a mother who’s a domestic violence victim, a family member who’s been incarcerated, a loss of a parent through divorce or abandonment. He later added emotional and physical neglect, for a total of 10 types of adverse childhood experiences, or ACEs.

The initial surveys began in 1995 and continued through 1997, with the participants followed subsequently for more than fifteen years. “Everything we’ve published comes from that baseline survey of 17,421 people,” says Anda, as well as what was learned by following those people for so long.

When the first results of the survey were due to come in, Anda was at home in Atlanta. Late in the evening, he logged into his computer to look at the findings. He was stunned. “I wept,” he says. “I saw how much people had suffered and I wept.”

This was the first time that researchers had looked at the effects of several types of trauma, rather than the consequences of just one. What the data revealed was mind-boggling.

The first shocker: There was a direct link between childhood trauma and adult onset of chronic disease, as well as mental illness, doing time in prison, and work issues, such as absenteeism.

The second shocker: About two-thirds of the adults in the study had experienced one or more types of adverse childhood experiences. Of those, 87 percent had experienced 2 or more types. This showed that people who had an alcoholic father, for example, were likely to have also experienced physical abuse or verbal abuse. In other words, ACEs usually didn’t happen in isolation.

The third shocker: More adverse childhood experiences resulted in a higher risk of medical, mental and social problems as an adult.

To explain this, Anda and Felitti developed a scoring system for ACEs. Each type of adverse childhood experience counted as one point. If a person had none of the events in her or his background, the ACE score was zero. If someone was verbally abused thousands of times during his or her childhood, but no other types of childhood trauma occurred, this counted as one point in the ACE score. If a person experienced verbal abuse, lived with a mentally ill mother and an alcoholic father, his ACE score was three.

Things start getting serious around an ACE score of 4. Compared with people with zero ACEs, those with four categories of ACEs had a 240 percent greater risk of hepatitis, were 390 percent more likely to have chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (emphysema or chronic bronchitis), and a 240 percent higher risk of a sexually-transmitted disease.

They were twice as likely to be smokers, 12 times more likely to have attempted suicide, seven times more likely to be alcoholic, and 10 times more likely to have injected street drugs.

People with high ACE scores are more likely to be violent, to have more marriages, more broken bones, more drug prescriptions, more depression, more auto-immune diseases, and more work absences.

“Some of the increases are enormous and are of a size that you rarely ever see in health studies or epidemiological studies. It changed my thinking dramatically,” says Anda.

Two in nine people had an ACE score of 3 or more, and one in eight had an ACE score of 4 or more. This means that every physician probably sees several high ACE score patients every day, notes Felitti. “Typically, they are the most difficult, though the underpinnings will rarely be recognized.”

The kicker was this: The ACE Study participants were average Americans. Seventy-five percent were white, 11 percent Latino, 7.5 percent Asian and Pacific Islander, and 5  percent were black. They were middle-class, middle-aged, 36 percent had attended college and 40 percent had college degrees or higher. Since they were members of Kaiser Permanente, they all had jobs and great health care. Their average age was 57.

As Anda has said: “It’s not just ‘them’. It’s us.”

Changing the landscape of understanding human development

In the last 14 years, Anda, Felitti and other CDC researchers have published more than 60 papers in prestigious peer-reviewed journals, including the Journal of the American Medical Association and the American Journal of Preventive Medicine. Other researchers have referenced their work more than 1,500 times. Anda and Felitti have flown around the U.S., Canada and Europe to give hundreds of speeches.

Their inquiry “changed the landscape,” says Dr. Frank Putnam, director of the Mayerson Center for Safe and Healthy Children at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center and professor at the University of Cincinnati Department of Pediatrics. “It changed the landscape because of the pervasiveness of ACEs in the huge number of public health problems, expensive public health problems — depression, substance abuse, STDs, cancer, heart disease, chronic lung disease, diabetes.”

The ACE Study became even more significant with the publication of parallel research that provided the link between why something that happened to you when you were a kid could land you in the hospital at age 50. The stress of severe and chronic childhood trauma – such as being regularly hit, constantly belittled and berated, watching your father often hit your mother – releases hormones that physically damage a child’s developing brain.

Flight, fight or freeze hormones work really well to help us accelerate when we’re being chased by a vicious dog with big teeth, fight when we’re cornered, or turn to stone and stop breathing to escape detection by a predator. But they become toxic when they’re turned on for too long.

This was determined by a group of neuroscientists and pediatricians, including neuroscientist Martin Teicher and pediatrician Jack Shonkoff, both at Harvard University, neuroscientist Bruce McEwen at Rockefeller University, and child psychiatrist Bruce Perry at the Child Trauma Academy.

As San Francisco pediatrician Nadine Burke Harris recently explained to host Ira Glass on the radio program, “This American Life”, if you’re in a forest and see a bear, a very efficient fight or flight system instantly floods your body with adrenaline and cortisol and shuts off the thinking portion of your brain that would stop to consider other options. This is very helpful if you’re in a forest and you need to run from a bear. “The problem is when that bear comes home from the bar every night,” she said.

Dr. Nadine Burke Harris and faux patient (for the photo)

If a bear threatens a child every single day, his emergency response system is activated over and over and over again. He’s always ready to fight or flee from the bear, but the part of his brain – the prefrontal cortex – that’s called upon to diagram a sentence or do math becomes stunted, because, in our brains, emergencies – such as fleeing bears – take precedence over doing math.

For Harris’ patients who had four or more categories of adverse childhood experiences “their odds of having learning or behavior problems in school were 32 times as high as kids who had no adverse childhood experiences,” she told Glass.

Together, the two discoveries – the ACE epidemiology and the brain research — reveal a story too compelling to ignore:

Children with toxic stress live much of their lives in fight, flight or fright (freeze) mode. They respond to the world as a place of constant danger. With their brains overloaded with stress hormones and unable to function appropriately, they can’t focus on learning. They fall behind in school or fail to develop healthy relationships with peers or create problems with teachers and principals because they are unable to trust adults. Some kids do all three. With despair, guilt and frustration pecking away at their psyches, they often find solace in food, alcohol, tobacco, methamphetamines, inappropriate sex, high-risk sports, and/or work and over-achievement. They don’t regard these coping methods as problems. Consciously or unconsciously, they use them as solutions to escape from depression, anxiety, anger, fear and shame.

What all this means, says Anda is that we need to prevent adverse childhood experiences and, at the same time, change our systems – educational, criminal justice, healthcare, mental health, public health, workplace – so that we don’t further traumatize someone who’s already traumatized. You can’t do one or the other and hope to make any progress.

“Dr. Putnam is right — ACEs changed the landscape,” Anda says. “Or perhaps the many publications from the ACE Study opened our eyes to see the truth of the landscape. ACEs create a “chronic public health disaster”that until recently has been hidden by our limited vision. Now we see that the biologic impacts of ACEs transcend the traditional boundaries of our siloed health and human service systems. Children affected by ACEs appear in all human service systems throughout the lifespan — childhood, adolescence, and adulthood — as clients with behavioral, learning, social, criminal, and chronic health problems.”

But our society has tended to treat the abuse, maltreatment, violence and chaotic experiences of our children as an oddity instead of commonplace, as the ACE Study revealed, notes Anda. And our society believes that these experiences are adequately dealt with by emergency response systems such as child protective services, criminal justice, foster care, and alternative schools. “These services are needed and are worthy of support — but they are a dressing on a greater wound,” he says.

“A hard look at the public health disaster calls for the both the prevention and treatment ACEs,” he continues. “This will require integration of educational, criminal justice, healthcare, mental health, public health, and corporate systems that involves sharing of knowledge and resources that will replace traditional fragmented approaches to burden of adverse childhood experiences in our society.”

As Williamson, the epidemiologist who introduced Felitti and Anda, and also worked on the ACE Study, says: “It’s not just a social worker’s problem. It’s not just a psychologist’s problem. It’s not just a pediatrician’s problem. It’s not just a juvenile court judge’s problem.” In other words, this is everybody’s problem.

According to a CDC study released earlier this year, just one year of confirmed cases of child maltreatment costs $124 billion over the lifetime of the traumatized children. The researchers based their calculations on only confirmed cases of physical, sexual and verbal abuse and neglect, which child maltreatment experts say is a small percentage of what actually occurs.

The breakdown per child is:

•       $32,648 in childhood health care costs

•       $10,530 in adult medical costs

•       $144,360 in productivity losses

•       $7,728 in child welfare costs

•       $6,747 in criminal justice costs

•       $7,999 in special education costs

You’d think the overwhelming amount of money spent on the fallout of adverse childhood experiences would have inspired the medical community, the public health community and federal, state and local governments to integrate this knowledge and fund programs that have been proven to prevent ACEs. But adoption of concepts from the ACE Study and the brain research has been remarkably slow and uneven.

On the federal level, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) – probably the largest federal agency you never heard of – launched the National Child Traumatic Stress Network in 2001, and the National Center for Trauma-Informed Care (NCTIC) in 2005. Much of the work focused on stress from individual traumatic events, or individual types of child abuse; only recently has there been a focus on dysfunctional families or changing systems that engage those families to become trauma-informed, i.e., not further traumatizing already traumatized people, as so many of our systems do.

Until the last 10 months, the medical community practically ignored the ACE Study. Just last December, the American Academy of Pediatrics issued a policy statement recommended that its members look for toxic stress in their patients. Except with local exceptions, the public health community has not embraced it. In fact, the CDC — the one agency you might think would use its own research to reorganize how it approaches prevention of alcohol, obesity, sexually transmitted diseases and smoking — has whittled down funding for the ACE Study to practically nothing, and nobody’s working on it full time.

However, on a local and state level, there’s been considerably more action. Washington was the first state to embrace the ACE Study and the research on children’s developing brains, when its Family Policy Council distributed the information  through a statewide network of 42 communities. Over the last three years, 18 states have done their own ACE surveys, with results similar to the CDC study.

Some cities have set up ACE task forces. Trauma-informed practices are popping up around the U.S., Canada, and countries in Europe, Asia, and Central and South America in schools, prisons, mental clinics and hospitals, a few pediatric practices, crisis nurseries, local public health departments, homeless shelters, at least one hospital emergency room, substance-abuse clinics, child welfare services, youth services, domestic violence shelters, rehab centers for seniors, residential treatment centers for girls and boys, and courtrooms.

In these dozens of organizations, the results of the new approach are nothing less than astounding: the most hopeless of lives turned around, parents speaking “ACEs” and determined not to pass on their high ACEs to their children, and a significant reduction in costs of health care, social services and criminal justice.

___________________

If you’re interested in becoming more involved in the PACEs science community, join our companion social network, PACEs Connection. Just go to PACEsConnection.com and click “Join”. PACEsConnection.com is the leading advocate for information about the science of positive and adverse childhood experiences (PACEs) and the rapidly expanding, global PACEs science movement. 

376 comments

  3. […] ACE’s no matter how long ago they occurred. References http://www.cdc.gov/ace/findings.htm https://acestoohigh.com/2012/10/03/the-adverse-childhood-experiences-study-the-largest-most-importan… Van der Kolk, B., (2014). The body keeps the score. New York, New York: […]

    Like

    Reply

  4. […] In 1985, Dr. Vincent Felitti was investigating why patients in his San Diego obesity clinic were dropping out of the program, even when they were seeing impressive progress in losing weight. He and his staff interviewed nearly 200 of the people who chose to drop out of the program. Eventually, he began to see an unsettling trend: a significant number of those interviewed had experienced sexual abuse as a child. These patients were using eating as a coping mechanism for the stress they continued to feel because of their childhood traumas. Dr. Felitti took these findings to a meeting of the North American Association for the Study of Obesity in 1990. The experts there suggested that his patients were lying to him! Fortunately, the contacts made at that meeting led to the involvement of the epidemiology department of the CDC. Together, Felitti, who worked for the Department of Preventive Medicine at Kaiser Permanente in San Diego, and Dr. Robert Anda, a medical epidemiologist with the CDC, created a set of questions to add to the medical questionnaire filled out by each patient who came through the department. Out of the roughly 26,000 patients who were seen in his department, Felitti received agreement from 17,421 to participate in the ACE study (Felitti et al., 1998; Felitti, 2002; Stevens, 2012) […]

    Like

    Reply

  19. […] “Trauma” has become a bit of a buzzword around the internet. This is the case in part because more and more research and understanding of trauma has come to light, and we’re better articulating the impact of trauma on the body and mind. Trauma is an emotional response to an event; it is not the event itself. Perhaps the easiest way to think of trauma is that the body’s natural fight, flight, or freeze response — which normally is a short lived experience — does not dissipate once the triggering incident ends. It is being consistently on guard, with less and less opportunity to shut down the body’s sympathetic nervous system. There are many life situations that create trauma for a person, and because it is so individual, some are more sensitive while others are more resilient. It is, of course, much more likely for those living in the margins to have more trauma than those who fit the cishet, white, Christian mold. Young people are especially vulnerable to trauma, as those experiences directly impact their development (and if this is a thing you’re interested in knowing more about, dig into the Adverse Childhood Experiences Study*). […]

    Like

    Reply

  20. […] “Trauma” has become a bit of a buzzword around the internet. This is the case in part because more and more research and understanding of trauma has come to light, and we’re better articulating the impact of trauma on the body and mind. Trauma is an emotional response to an event; it is not the event itself. Perhaps the easiest way to think of trauma is that the body’s natural fight, flight, or freeze response — which normally is a short lived experience — does not dissipate once the triggering incident ends. It is being consistently on guard, with less and less opportunity to shut down the body’s sympathetic nervous system. There are many life situations that create trauma for a person, and because it is so individual, some are more sensitive while others are more resilient. It is, of course, much more likely for those living in the margins to have more trauma than those who fit the cishet, white, Christian mold. Young people are especially vulnerable to trauma, as those experiences directly impact their development (and if this is a thing you’re interested in knowing more about, dig into the Adverse Childhood Experiences Study*). […]

    Like

    Reply

  21. […] “Trauma” has become a bit of a buzzword around the internet. This is the case in part because more and more research and understanding of trauma has come to light, and we’re better articulating the impact of trauma on the body and mind. Trauma is an emotional response to an event; it is not the event itself. Perhaps the easiest way to think of trauma is that the body’s natural fight, flight, or freeze response — which normally is a short lived experience — does not dissipate once the triggering incident ends. It is being consistently on guard, with less and less opportunity to shut down the body’s sympathetic nervous system. There are many life situations that create trauma for a person, and because it is so individual, some are more sensitive while others are more resilient. It is, of course, much more likely for those living in the margins to have more trauma than those who fit the cishet, white, Christian mold. Young people are especially vulnerable to trauma, as those experiences directly impact their development (and if this is a thing you’re interested in knowing more about, dig into the Adverse Childhood Experiences Study*). […]

    Like

    Reply

  22. […] “Trauma” has become a bit of a buzzword around the internet. This is the case in part because more and more research and understanding of trauma has come to light, and we’re better articulating the impact of trauma on the body and mind. Trauma is an emotional response to an event; it is not the event itself. Perhaps the easiest way to think of trauma is that the body’s natural fight, flight, or freeze response — which normally is a short lived experience — does not dissipate once the triggering incident ends. It is being consistently on guard, with less and less opportunity to shut down the body’s sympathetic nervous system. There are many life situations that create trauma for a person, and because it is so individual, some are more sensitive while others are more resilient. It is, of course, much more likely for those living in the margins to have more trauma than those who fit the cishet, white, Christian mold. Young people are especially vulnerable to trauma, as those experiences directly impact their development (and if this is a thing you’re interested in knowing more about, dig into the Adverse Childhood Experiences Study*). […]

    Like

    Reply

  23. […] “Trauma” has become a bit of a buzzword around the internet. This is the case in part because more and more research and understanding of trauma has come to light, and we’re better articulating the impact of trauma on the body and mind. Trauma is an emotional response to an event; it is not the event itself. Perhaps the easiest way to think of trauma is that the body’s natural fight, flight, or freeze response — which normally is a short lived experience — does not dissipate once the triggering incident ends. It is being consistently on guard, with less and less opportunity to shut down the body’s sympathetic nervous system. There are many life situations that create trauma for a person, and because it is so individual, some are more sensitive while others are more resilient. It is, of course, much more likely for those living in the margins to have more trauma than those who fit the cishet, white, Christian mold. Young people are especially vulnerable to trauma, as those experiences directly impact their development (and if this is a thing you’re interested in knowing more about, dig into the Adverse Childhood Experiences Study*). […]

    Like

    Reply

  24. […] “Trauma” has develop into a little bit of a buzzword across the web. This is the case partly as a result of increasingly more analysis and understanding of trauma has come to gentle, and we’re higher articulating the influence of trauma on the physique and thoughts. Trauma is an emotional response to an occasion; it’s not the occasion itself. Perhaps the best approach to consider trauma is that the physique’s pure struggle, flight, or freeze response — which usually is a brief lived expertise — doesn’t dissipate as soon as the triggering incident ends. It is being persistently on guard, with much less and fewer alternative to close down the physique’s sympathetic nervous system. There are many life conditions that create trauma for an individual, and since it’s so particular person, some are extra delicate whereas others are extra resilient. It is, in fact, more likely for these residing within the margins to have extra trauma than those that match the cishet, white, Christian mildew. Young people are especially vulnerable to trauma, as these experiences straight influence their growth (and if this can be a factor you’re fascinated about realizing extra about, dig into the Adverse Childhood Experiences Study*). […]

    Like

    Reply

  48. […] This study was conducted by the CDC in 1995-1997 and included 17, 421 participants. The participants were followed for more than 15 years. The ACE Study participants were 75 percent white, 11 percent Latino, 7.5 percent Asian and Pacific Islander, and 5 percent were black. They were middle-class, middle-aged, 36 percent had attended college, and 40 percent had college degrees or higher. Their average age was 57. They all had jobs and excellent health care. Read more about this study here. […]

    Like

    Reply

  52. Thank you so much for your hard work and dedication. I am a Kenyan. I wonder: is there a similar program going on in Africa? Or, is it possible to start one? I know there are many Kenyans who would benefit from such. In the recent past, there have been rising cases of suicides, homicides, alcohol and substance abuse among the Kenyan youth and I am worried for my country people. What can I do while here to bring about some positive changes? Reading the article reminded me of my own dysfunctional family. My father left when I was barely one and I remember growing up crying myself to bed most nights wishing he was around, wishing he had been strong enough and loved us enough to stay. I did not realize how that had affected me until much later in life when I would naturally gravitate towards older men and unhealthy relationships based on sex all so I could find the solace and love that my father never afforded me. I am great now, and I am thankful for that, though I know there are people in Kenya who have had it (or are still having it) worse than I did and I just want to help.

    Like

    Reply

    • Please join PACEsConnection.com, the social network that accompanies ACEsTooHigh.com. It’s free. There is a PACEs initiative in Kenya. Go to the home page, and search for it in the Communities section in the upper navigation bar.

      Like

      Reply

  57. […] The ACES study began in an obesity clinic in 1985, believe it or not. Physicians were interested in figuring out why people kept dropping out of their weight loss program; long story short, they developed the Adverse Childhood Experiences Scale and administered it to their patients. The results were unprecedented: they uncovered a link between childhood trauma and struggles with controlling their weight later in … […]

    Like

    Reply

  64. What year and in what study did Dr Anda include 10 questions on the ACEs questionnaire? I cannot find the reference anywhere..

    Like

    Reply

  71. […] particular interest to me after struggling with obesity all of my adult life, was this story of how The Adverse Childhood Experiences Study — the largest, most important public health study you neve…, and the statistic that people with with a score of six or higher died 20 years prematurely. Wow. […]

    Like

    Reply

  75. Recognizing the critical role parents have in the total health of future generations we need to support parent education programs beginning in grade school for both children and for
    parents. Public educators must take the leadership role to disseminate the Acestudy.org findings, build support and encourage community participation. Expanding Family Counseling programs and offering parents options such as FACES / Families And Counselors in Educational Settings can be a start.

    Like

    Reply

  76. This is a marvelous work and my marriage has been restored and my spouse is back to me just in 24 hours..i was truly flabbergasted and shocked when my Husband knelt down begging for forgiveness and for me to accept him back.. I am really short of words and joy, and i don’t know how much to convey my appreciation to you Robinson Buckler you are a God sent to me and my entire family.. And now i am a happy man once again..Robinsonbuckler { @ } yahoo . com🙂

    Like

    Reply

  77. I wanted to send links for all three articles published in huffungton post but end up at dead ends for the others. Is there a way to access?

    Josie

    Like

    Reply

  79. […] One of the most monumental studies to ever be published in the field of trauma and psychology is the Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study. The study has been deemed one of the most significant predictors of mental and physical health. For a bit of context, the ACE study developed out of an incidental finding through another study that was seeking to establish why certain weight loss clients were regaining weight following surgery. In that study, there was an odd correlation with histories of sexual abuse and weight gain. What followed was a mass survey of 17,421 people. The outcomes of this survey found the following: T… […]

    Like

    Reply

  82. Dr. Felitti and Dr. Anda, I appreciate all of your work regarding the ACE study. Mind-blowing! Please know that I’m using it in my work as a forensic social worker and mitigation specialist working on death penalty cases in the Federal criminal justice system.

    Like

    Reply

  92. […] to understand why most obese people regained the weight they lost, an obesity researcher made an accidental discovery — the majority of his study subjects had been sexually abused as children or sexually assaulted […]

    Like

    Reply

  97. […] and chief of Kaiser Permanente’s Department of Preventive Medicine in San Diego, California, was trying to figure out why more than half the people in his obesity clinic dropped out of the program, even when they were […]

    Like

    Reply

  106. I recently began studying ACEs. I had come to conclusions of my own regarding my physical problems and my adverse childhood experiences. My personal experiences with ACEs had led me to the same conclusion about that as the researchers found in the survey work they did. My medical expensess are outrageous every year. I have POTs, adrenal insuffiency, fibromyalgia, chronic fatugue syndrome, asthma, Graves Disease, migraine headaches. My mental health diagnoses are PTSD, Major Depression, Borderline Personality Disorder. I am also a licensed clinical counselor in Ohio. I have spent the last 30 years trying to understand myself. Now I am 71 years old. My family denied the whole thing, church people believe I’m crazy, My husband has not a clue as to how to deal with me. I am still looking for some one to help me. I have maintained normal weight, was successful in school, have no substance abuse issues. I wonder how I managed all of that with an ACE score of 5.

    Like

    Reply

    • Because you inner will and strength must be phenomenal on a conscious level. Its clearly still impacting you unconsciously x Have you read The body keeps score? See a Hypnotherapist and try Regression. I can look in my group to find one near you.

      Like

      Reply

      • “The Body Keeps the Score” was a life-changing read for me. I hope I will never stop trying to figure out how to advocate for change.

        Like

    • I hope you’ve had the opportunity to get help. If you’re still searching, working with a therapist who’s familiar with somatic work such as Somatic Experiencing developed by Peter Levine has been extremely helpful to many.
      Information is available at https://traumahealing.org/. The list of practitioners maybe found on the website.

      Like

      Reply

  111. […] “What all this means, says Anda (Dr. Robert Anda) is that we need to prevent adverse childhood experiences and, at the same time, change our systems – educational, criminal justice, healthcare, mental health, public health, workplace – so that we don’t further traumatize someone who’s already traumatized. You can’t do one or the other and hope to make any progress.” – Jane Ellen Stevens Click for more: Aces Too High […]

    Like

    Reply

  115. I for one am curious how many clients of this clinic mentioned what I sometimes call the “fat-hate feedback loop”. Many adipose people I know could well answer to having suffered several types of ACEs precisely because they were either objectively or subjectively perceived as “overweight” and subjected to various levels of ill treatment, sometimes quite severe, by schoolmates, by parents, by doctors. Often I have heard people say things on the order of “I look back at my school pictures, and I wasn’t even that fat, but everyone told me I was”. The crafters of the messaging about childhood obesity evidently have little ability to see how smacking of an authoritarian surveillance state some of it can look to the intended recipients. Forced contact is a sexual assault everyone recognizes, but for many fat adolescents, just as much a sexual assault is the suggestion that some few extra pounds will make them unattractive to anyone, a suggestion that is not only heartless, but not even remotely true. In fact especially adolescent girls who are tall as well as heavy tell of being told such insinuations of ugliness one moment, then the next mistaken for adult women and having to handle adult males’ sexual overtures. These things are the drivers of all manner of confusion and suicidal ideation and reckless attempts at weight reduction. “If you’d just lose the weight you wouldn’t have any problem” is precisely an instance of parents’ failure to defend which I’ve heard all too often. And if adverse stress is a causative factor in weight gain, one can easily see a feedback loop setting up where gains in weight are met with all manner of abusive responses which ratchet up the stress level, generating a triple-spiral of weight, health problems, and social abuses. A person in this cycle might lose weight, but the internalized and externally reinforced messaging about weight is still there, and so well may be the health issues. To my mind the only sustainable way to break this cycle is to work to arrest abusive treatment of fat children and give all children plenty of positive messaging that their potential matters no matter how their bodies are shaped.

    Like

    Reply

  116. What are your sources for this backstory? utilizing ACEs in my dissertation and wanting to know more about the backstory as to how the ACEs study came about.

    Like

    Reply

    • I appreciate the ACE information..I am a person who has an ACE score of 10. I struggle to find help that embraces the ACE idea of an integrative approach.. I do not smoke. I do not drink 13 years). I have done weight loss programs and weight came off and came back. I have been diagnosed with PTSD. I think more like CPTSD for obvious reasons. I do work with a therapist and a psychiatrist. I work and do find that the work stress triggers me physically despite me doing healthy things to mitigate. I am contemplating bariatric surgery and came across this article trying to find out if this is going to be successful or if this is going to be another exercise in futility.

      Liked by 2 people

      Reply

      • Hi Virginia: I am PeTe a retired clinical psychologist with many years of experience treating adults who had been abused and or molested as children. Please reread this statement by Dr. Nadine Burke Harris, ” if you’re in a forest and see a bear, a very efficient fight or flight system instantly floods your body with adrenaline and cortisol and shuts off the thinking portion of your brain that would stop to consider other options. This is very helpful if you’re in a forest and you need to run from a bear. “The problem is when that bear comes home from the bar every night,” she said.
        If a bear threatens a child every single day, his emergency response system is activated over and over and over again. He’s always ready to fight or flee from the bear, but the part of his brain – the prefrontal cortex – that’s called upon to diagram a sentence or do math becomes stunted, because, in our brains, emergencies – such as fleeing bears – take precedence over doing math.

        For Harris’ patients who had four or more categories of adverse childhood experiences “their odds of having learning or behavior problems in school were 32 times as high as kids who had no adverse childhood experiences,
        So in cases like yours you can count on there being abnormal responses in your brain to stress.
        I suggest to you that any job or lifestyle which has more than minimal stress, although you can certainly handle it better than most, will cause you to remain in chronic stress mode and will keep many of your normal brain functions from working properly. I think that you would best build a life with minimal stress and make sure you have loving supportive people in your social life and minimal stress in your work. I suggest that group therapy with other ACEs victims with varying time in recovery would be very valuable for you so smooth your reactions and responses to life events.
        I discovered that my ACEs score is 8 after many years of treating these wonderful people and I decided to calm things down in my life due to my tendency to over react in terms of what is good for my general health. My life is now much more calm and I am happier with a calmer life with much less stress after years of healing with others in similar life situations. I have become a devoted Christian, which provides fellowship and an opportunity to come to know the bible which has greatly helped me find ways of operating, which have improved my life immeasurably.

        I hope that this helps you my fellow traveler. PeTe

        Like

      • You might want to look at EMDR therapy before you try bariatric surgery. It must get be helpful. It is recognized by the World Health Organization as efficacious for treating trauma. It changed my life. Hope things get better for you. Leslye

        Like

      • Can you believe that in Rochester, NY, the head of psychiatry and Unity Health System has forbidden all therapists to use EMDR because he read on the internet (at QuackWatch.org) that EMDR is a farce. Dr. Michael McGrath is also working to disprove the theory of freeze response.

        Liked by 1 person

    • Research has shown that it’s not necessarily the specific technique used in therapy that renders the highest curative potency to mental demoralization but rather the the therapeutic relationship between the client and therapist. Common factors that contribute to relief from mental anguish stem first and foremost from the unconditional positive regard, empathic listening without judgement, and the trusting bond forged in the therapeutic relationship. From this foundation many techniques can be used with sucess because the foundation has been laid where the client believes in the treatment modality, the genuine intent of the therapist and feels valued as human being. Often for the first time in their lives. So wether it’s EMDR or CBT or REBT or … The demoralization that precipitates from childhood trauma and persists through adulthood can be decreased via therapy with a compassionate and competent mental health counselor.

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply

  148. On behalf of the medical community, I hereby apologize to our populace for
    our delay in facing this key epidemic.
    Ignorance is not a good excuse. People who taught self-defense classes,
    ran For Men Against Sexism workshops, worked at battered-people’s shelters, or lent
    listening ears to their friends and relatives could bave told us all of this many decades
    ago–and, in fact, did.
    One of the things that got in the way of facing the truth was our own embarrassment.
    None of us is more than one or two degrees away from a perpetrator or victim
    of serious abuse, and all of us carry some bits of victimhood and abusiveness within our own psyches.
    Another is the way that health care is used as a profit-making industry. Taking
    good care of young people does not make huge profits for drug companies.
    Fortunately we have the means to change things. Here are two that are already ready for prime time:
    (1) Parenting support from HandinHandParenting.org — very effective at breaking
    the chain of mistreatment and very pro-parent as well as pro-child
    (2) Single-payer health care that makes health care a public good, not another way to exploit the victims.

    Liked by 2 people

    Reply

    • Thank you for your comment. If you’re interested in seeing how others, including those in the medical community, are integrating practices based on ACEs science, you may be interested in joining ACEsTooHigh’s companion social network, ACEsConnection.com.

      Cheers, Jane

      Liked by 2 people

      Reply

  149. This is all true in my life ! I am now working with a therapist who is helping me help the
    Child in me understand and care for
    Parents divorce at age 4 was the beginning
    Of my food issues -The mental abuse from family about my weigh. Mom controled my food intake , put me thru crazy weight programs The worst was Shick shock program
    Infertility has made it all worse -I know failure
    But success is scary !

    Like

    Reply

  150. This is very eye – opening. How can we protect all the poor children of the world who are pout through such misery. There should be screening tests for people who wish to be parents.

    Like

    Reply

  153. The wave of healing is growing, and nobody can stop it! There is so much hope because so many individuals have dedicated their lives to crafting healing arts. Check out new paradigms such as Internal Family Systems Therapy (IFS), Family Constellations, or Voice Dialogue. There are pioneers out here who have been doing the work and now we all can benefit. There is so much free information online to get you started. I have witnessed people heal from the most horrific atrocities, and I want anyone out there suffering to know that there is REAL HEALING available! I urge you to research these systems and other new trauma-healing systems that have developed over the last few decades. They aren’t mainstream yet, but they really work, and I really urge you to keep going because you can heal. Learn how to connect with your Higher Self with IFS and you will be amazed at how powerful and beautiful you really are.

    Like

    Reply

  155. […] It was 1985, and Dr. Vincent Felitti was mystified. The physician, chief of Kaiser Permanente’s revolutionary Department of Preventive Medicine in San Diego, CA, couldn’t figure out why, each year for the last five years, more than half of the people in his obesity clinic dropped out. (From Aces Too High News) […]

    Like

    Reply

  161. As a former (1974 to 1989) clinical psychologist specializing in adults molested and abused as children i can say that the people i worked with had significant physical, social and psychological challenges making a normal life impossible without significant intervention, which was very difficult for them always.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

    • Wow, you were doing that work back then! What a gem you must be. I wish my mother could have found help. She was looking. I’ve been looking my whole life. Finally with the new understanding of the part our “older” brain plays, I have found help to turn my nervous system around – it was shattered from years of developmental trauma. Now I’m building new pathways of thought and my body is unwinding from years of contraction patterns. It’s not easy. The more you heal, the more you feel. You can’t do it all at once. It’s scarier than fire walking.

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply

  171. Thanks for all the great information. I really appreciate what was brought up about not retraumatizing the already traumatized. I do not go anywhere near doctors offices, anymore, because I am very tired of having my intelligence insulted, denials of me knowing anything about how I feel or think or what has happened to me, and … oh, just so much crap, really.

    Going to a doctor is, generally, an expensive exercise in futility. I need someone who is going to listen and see me as a human being, not catch a few words here or there and remember what their textbook said. Going to a doctor is worse than talking to an IT department.

    It’s good to read about a couple of people who really want to help and the possibility of others following their lead. There are so few medical professionals out there who are really interested in their patients and out of those, well, I don’t know any a poor person can visit.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

    • Arletta: I am so sorry to hear that you have had this experience (not surprised but sorry). I became exhausted because when it was discovered that I would help adults molested as children, I was swamped with patients and had literally no one I could refer to. I trained others and eventually they became licensed and were competent but this is very hard work and very sad in the beginning because you have to identify the history and then start working on the effects on behavior and thinking VERY RESPECTFULLY cuz this is a kid making choices with no loving adult to help decide how to think and act.
      There may be good people who will handle your healing lovingly and with patience and at rates you can afford (group therapy is way helpful). you are right to be very demanding and to get out when you feel not cared about or not respected or not valued. This will be very difficult and must be guided by someone who cares and knows how to help and get through making mistakes along the way cuz we all make mistakes and people who love each other make fixing those mistakes a very high priority. I suggest that you watch out for know it alls. love, Pete

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply

  174. I wish I lived in the US right now! I think the work you are doing to help protect kids is amazing and long may it continue and fewer kids may not have to experience the terror of violent, abusive and neglectful parents. I watch the work of Bessel Van der Kolk and Peter Levine to mention but a few and I wish we had the understanding and the practitioners here in the UK.

    I have an ACE score of 10 plus though I do believe I must have some resilience or I would not still be here today! I have reached 52 and struggled all my life thinking I was just crazy, had adhd, thought I was weak as I was unable to say ‘NO’ to pretty much anything and agree to pretty much anything if I think it will please people. I don’t have any trouble remembering the bear coming home from the bar every night and beating my mother whilst we stood with pee running down our legs too scared to move and unable to protect her but once I got to 11 I could calm him by letting him sexually abuse me – disgusting but it kept my mother and brother safe sometimes. My parents were my abusers but after that I’ve ended up in a 25 year marriage with a very controlling man, I ran to him as he was ‘big and strong’ in the hope that he would always protect me from my father. Almost 12 months ago something inside me snapped and the ‘shell’ or the pretence of being an able, capable mum, post grad with a reasonably good job just stopped working I have no idea why and I am now in a state of emotional collapse. I have never been so less capable, unable to focus on anything, unable to concentrate. I have always suffered from chronic insomnia but just learned to live on very little sleep but I could do that in my 20’s, 30’s and 40’s but no more! I am in a complete and utter mess, no job, no income and everything seems so hopeless.

    I went to my doctor and tried to explain about my ACE score and he just looked at me and said I don’t know what you’re talking about. I asked for a psychiatric referral but was told I couldn’t have one? It seems there is no help available for me despite all of the years of tax paid to fund our National Health system. If I want help I must sort it out myself and sadly the cost is out of my reach. How do you start when the UK seems miles behind and doesn’t seem to want to admit there is a problem. I wish I could shout about ACEs from the rooftops and make people listen but given my mental state right now I will probably end up in jail! I feel so hopeless useless and worthless right now and I just don’t know what to do as my brain won’t seem to calm enough to think of anything sensibly. If anyone can suggest anything please do as I am lost.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

    • I’m so sorry that you experienced such a horrible childhood. Nobody should have to go through that. I suggest joining ACEsConnection.com, the companion social network to ACEsTooHigh.com, and looking for people in the UK who are members (currently, there are 98). Many of them are implementing trauma-informed, resilience-building practices based on ACEs science, or want to.

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply

      • Hi Jane,

        Thank you so very much I’ve been looking for stuff in aces in the uk and felt like I was getting nowhere fast! I will check it out.

        Thank you for your kindness

        Julia

        Liked by 1 person

    • I am in your place too – it is scary and hopeless. I have made a lot of progress with something called Associative Awareness Technique, but today I am in a bad place, feeling hopeless, spiraling into isolation more and more every day. I think I may in a deep form of “freeze” but knowing that doesn’t help. I was strong and fought my past for several decades, but the loss of a relationship 5 years ago plummeted me into a black hole. It was as if my initial childhood trauma had laid eggs. I have been trying to pull myself up by my boot straps but I keep falling down. My resistance is broken and triggers are killing me left and right.

      I think the real killer for me now is isolation. I don’t want to be with people. I am tired of small talk and being around other people’s happy families. I cannot talk about my reality to people – it is too disturbing for them. It would be nice to have a forum or support group.

      I think there should be a diagnosis called Compound Complex PTSD – when a person has spent decades under the rule of sadistic parental introjects. Now that I understand the nervous system better, I look back on many therapies and spiritual practices that I tried and realize that many of them embedded my trauma deeper. I think that there are barely a handful of people in the world who know how to help people like us, and it is a dangerous road. The more you heal, the more you feel.

      Like

      Reply

      • Teresa,
        I feel your encompassing range of unwelcomed & uninvited emotions as well. Your post touched me in the center of my struggling heart & soul. I find many similarities in our situation and am pursuing positive options to overcome this life situation that has
        hung on far too long to find hope to overcome. My last relationship ended 7 years ago, kids are grown & gone, rarely hear from them and I feel isolated &very
        much alone. The upside I hold onto is my morals, values, & ability to read & reach out to those I find in need of comfort or help. However, I have also found this to be a double edged sword where I have been used & abused. I send this message to you in hopes that you find hope to smile and feel value in the special person you seem to be and agree that an educated support group or forum would be so beneficial for us all.

        Liked by 1 person

      • Dear Julia. I feel you are so brave to come out with your story as your story is so much like mine. I lost my identical twin sister 3 years ago and now I understand why I am coming apart spiraling down and always wanting to be alone yet I still I don’t like loneliness. A year after my twin died, I had a major stroke. I lost the one person who knew what we went through. WE were each other’s support. Im a high ACES.

        Liked by 1 person

    • HI Jules: Just read your message. I really feel for you my dear. My only suggestion is that you read what is put up here and let it guide your life until the UK medical community is shamed into facing this major cultural issue and starts making treatment available for people like us. You could also advertise for others in the same position and start a self help group meeting and talk about what is found in these messages. I think that would be a step in the right direction anyway. I do think that writing your powers that be and sending them some of the materials available about ACEs might also produce some movement in your culture. Love, PeTe

      Like

      Reply

  189. Hopefully something to bring people’s perspectives together. In my field, this is a given. Take it to the Suits, Wallets and decision makers, and it is irrelevant. Too many monoliths to listen to the tiny and most damaged voices, classified most often as Borderline and Antisocial Personality Disorders. There is a point on the timeline that the Syndrome becomes the survival instinct, when the victim becomes a Community Problem and requires traumatizing treatment. I could go on and on.
    Very frustrating.

    Like

    Reply

  193. What about those who were abused by school teachers, or some one at Church. These also were ACEs. Can you develop questions that reflect that? If you restrict my childhood abuse to my immediate family my ACE is 1. If you include Educational and Spiritual Abuse my ACE is 3.

    Also what about children of those with high ACE scores? My mother was an ACE 4.

    Like

    Reply

    • Hi, Steven: There are, of course, many other types of childhood trauma — watching a sibling being abused, losing a caregiver (grandmother, mother, grandfather, etc.), homelessness, surviving and recovering from a severe accident, witnessing a father being abused by a mother, witnessing a grandmother abusing a father, etc. The ACE Study included only those 10 childhood traumas because those were mentioned as most common by a group of about 300 Kaiser members; those traumas were also well studied individually in the research literature.

      Some people are adding questions to the survey — I know of three pediatric clinics that have added four to six additional questions — and other organizations are assessing the types of childhood trauma reported by the populations they’re serving to add them to the 10-question survey.

      The most important thing to remember is that the ACE score is meant as a guideline: If you experienced other types of toxic stress, such as those you mentioned, then they can also affect your health and well-being.

      Like

      Reply

    • I don’t think this article discounts your experience. Why did you feel you couldn’t let your family know you were being harmed?

      Like

      Reply

      • When I was serxally abused between the ages of 5 and 10, how did I know as a child, what was normal. I was a frigging child! Why/How would I know to ask?

        Like

  239. How does a woman with ACES effect the relationship with her husband? My wife is constantly mad at me and treats me like her father with was the reason for her ACES. We have now been married almost 9 years and I just can’t stand her mental abuse any longer.

    Like

    Reply

  244. […] So, if you were Vincent Felitti, whom would you pick as your first audience to reveal your stunning findings? A group relatively informed about obesity that would greet the new information with extreme interest, praise and applause? Natch. So, in 1990, Felitti flew to Atlanta to give a speech to the members – many of them psychologists and psychiatrists — of the North American Association for the Study of Obesity. The audience listened quietly and politely. When he finished, one of the experts stood up and blasted him. “He told me I was naïve to believe my patients, that it was commonly understood by those more familiar with such matters that these patient statements were fabrications to provide a cover explanation for failed lives!”   https://acestoohigh.com/2012/10/03/the-adverse-childhood-experiences-study-the-largest-most-important… […]

    Like

    Reply

  245. I am 53, ACE score of 7. I left home at 18 and have been seeking professional help my entire life. I wish it were so simple as “change your thoughts change your life” but it’s not – I have tried all of these avenues. What I have found is a body of work based on the “freeze response” (when you cannot fight or flee). Peter A Levine did some of the most important ground breaking work on this and developed a form of therapy called Somatic Experiencing, but there are others who have taken this body of knowledge into the realm of physical therapy, where the work can be done by addressing the brain stem and amygdala, which really run the show. I was able to stop all of my meds for sleeping and depression. Life is so different without the burden of those side-effects on my system, and the drugs never fixed anything – at any dose. Anyway, neurologist Robert Scaer has a huge body of work on trauma and the freeze response. His web site is traumasoma.com. The modality that helped me, and which I am still using is called Associative Awareness Technique, developed by Scott Musgrave. (http://www.wellnessandperformance.com) Bit by bit my feeling-self is coming back into my body, which was a very unsafe place for it to be. I am also practicing the Feldenkrais method of somatic awareness. For me, they work together well.

    Like

    Reply

    • Thank you for your comment Teresa. Your journey and persistence is a gift for us all. I continue to learn about more sources as each person shares their story, what’s helping, and the rewards of doing this work at various levels: personal, interpersonal community and beyond.

      Like

      Reply

    • Teresa- We seem to be on a similar path! I discovered AAT through a local physical therapist 2 1/2 years ago and have since read Levine, Scaer, and everything I can find about trauma and healing from it. Interesting that you use Feldenkrais- I am just starting to learn about it after reading that Dr. Merzenich, one of the pioneers in neuroplasticity research, is a huge fan of it. I have found a similar practice, Continuum Movement, very helpful already. I also practice sitting meditation and use mindfulness awareness techniques throughout my day. I think the best and most readily accessible instruction in these techniques remains Jon Kabat-Zinn’s book Full Catastrophe Living. I strongly believe the healing I experienced from AAT bodywork enabled me to begin consistently practicing meditation and mindfulness, after I had been doing AAT for over a year. It is particularly difficult for traumatized people to sit still with their body and mind, though this practice is so very valuable and creates so much positive transformation in the brain. For this reason, the Trauma Center in Brookline, Mass uses trauma-informed yoga classes to help their patients ease into the experience of being with their breath and body. I think this is an interesting approach, but somehow, and I hope someday to fully understand how, the AAT tools have been profoundly effective for enabling me to do this. Also, I should mention another powerful healing technique I recently discovered and now use almost daily is Tapas Acupressure Technique (TATlife.com- basic instructions can be downloaded for free.) Wishing you blessing and awakening on your healing journey, Teresa!

      Like

      Reply

      • Hi Pamela, I’m glad to have connected with someone else who knows about this stuff. I love this site and am thrilled that it is here. I think there are a lot of reasons why our discoveries are hard to put out there. Robert Scaer has written about the inherent trauma in the field of medicine – the bullying that is passed down from one generation of doctors to another, including the horrible ritual of sleep-deprived residencies. They too are brain washed and would rather delight in telling someone to not eat sugar than to hear the reality of a life story of trauma. Living in a body that has been racked by physical and emotional trauma is no joy ride. Going to the gym only results in pain and injury. I would like a case to be made for a “trauma body”. When I first started AAT, the person I was working with told me “no more exercise for a while”. As the AAT begins to heal my brain, I can absorb the wisdom of Feldenkrais – there was a time I couldn’t take it in because lying on my back on the floor brings up memories of torture. At this point I cannot practice any type of meditation and I doubt I ever will. EFT and tapping techniques only put me in the most horrible of places. I can stroke my face gently but tapping doesn’t feel good. Being with my mind is like curling up in a basket of razor blades. The best I can do is connect with my body and my breath as I move through the day. Even my breath can hold me hostage. There are times when it is stuck and no amount of mindfulness will let it release. I am healed enough so that I can walk and that is my meditation. I hope someday that I can experience joy, but for now I am grateful that episodes of despair are not as long or devastating as they used to be. I once had a therapist reprimand me: “there are no adult victims in my practice”. Well, goody for him. I hope, as the attention is put on children at risk, that someone out there realizes that adults need care too. It is people like us, if given a chance, who can carry the torch through the darkness.

        Like

      • Teresa, you write so eloquently and poignantly about your experience. Thank you for replying. Compared to what you describe, my life has been a picnic, and yet I know how very shut down I was and unable to feel, without understanding why, or even realizing that there was any other way to *be* in the world, and in my body. From what you describe, I would highly recommend again that you look at TAT and maybe consider doing a Skye session with Tapas Flemming. She is offering a discount on sessions through December but it can be used next year. While TAT is the same genera as EFT/Tapping, “energy psychology,” it is a different approach, involving holding specific points on the face and head rather than tapping or moving one’s hands. Tapas is an acupuncturist, and began using her method to treat allergies. One day an allergy client mentioned that as they had been working with her allergy to salt (!) she was noticing a profound shift in her relationship to her own childhood trauma. It turned out that she had been sexually abused in a bar and afterwards was always given a bag of potato chips- hence the salt “allergy”! So Tapas began to use her technique for broader issues. The TATlife.com web site details all of this. I’ve found TAT to be very powerful and easy to use. I can actually feel energy flowing in my body as I do it, and I often get a lot of discharge/shaking when I am working with a particularly intense subject. It can be used for life trauma, general challenges, or for immediate relief, like how I am feeling in the moment.

        Another great resource is Dr. Stephen Porges, who developed the Polyvagal Theory that has informed many trauma treatment approaches including AAT. His writing can be slow to get through, but his interviews are wonderful as he talks engagingly about the clinical applications of his theory. You can find a lot of great info on his web site http://stephenporges.com. I liked the interview he did for this series in particular: https://www.entheos.com/Hardwiring-Happiness/Rick-Hanson

        BTW, Teresa, if you’d like to keep in touch you can find me on Facebook. Best, Pamela

        Like

  248. […] This is important enough that I wanted to share it again.  The traumas (or nurturance) we receive in childhood can affect us for a lifetime: aligning our values, limiting our dreams, degrading or elevating our self-worth, literally grooving our brains with pain or pleasure, contorting our bodies with trapped emotion… Such simple reasons why I’ve been willing to sacrifice anything for my children. Twice, I’ve walked away from the career I loved, because there was something more important: Nicki.  Jason. I see myself in them, that is all.  I feel the connection, that is all.  I know how badly, achingly badly, it hurt when my father was not there to raise me. My mother and father divorced when I was about…what?  Five?  Six?   I’m not sure.  I do know that I have no memory of playing ball with him, or wrestling, him helping me with my homework, or attending a school play, or anything like that.  And that, for reasons I did not discover for another fifty years, he was never there for me afterward. I was so hungry for that energy.  Being raised by my mother and my sister Joyce, I certainly had the love I needed, but not the…force.  The Yang.  The ability to respond.   When other boys bullied me, pushed against me, I just wilted. So hungry that little boy I was.  So desperate not just to understand what it was to be male, but for a male to be willing to love me enough to teach me. Despite the fact that she had been a professional model, mom didn’t date much that I recall.    And for all I know I was a part of that.  I remember one day when I was perhaps seven, when one of her few beaus was at the house, sitting on the couch, and I curled up on a chair behind the couch like a little kitten or puppy.  Trying to be as cute and adorable as I could be. Won’t you be my Daddy..? Everything inside me screamed.  Am I so ugly, so stupid, such a twisted thing that no one wants to be my Daddy..? What a hole in my heart.  One it took another twenty years just to BEGIN to fill.  One I’ll never pass on to my children. Every day I deal with clients or students who are dealing with the consequences of a childhood of abuse, neglect, abandonment, or scrambled input.   Obesity, addictions, cutting, bulimia, abusive relationships, anger issues, PTSD and attendant stress/strain related disorders…it is killing people And can offer two basic pieces of advice: 1) Heal your own heart, and heal the relationship between the “child” and “adult” parts of your personality.  The Ancient Child meditation was initially created for this mighty purpose. 2) Find a child to care for.   Re-commit to your own children. Reach out to a niece or nephew, join Big Brothers or Big Sisters, adopt.  Get out of yourself to heal yourself. It’s never too late to have a happy childhood. Namaste, Steve https://acestoohigh.com/2012/10/03/the-adverse-childhood-experiences-study-the-largest-most-important… […]

    Like

    Reply

  264. Thank you so much for writing about this important topic, in such a good and creative way! This blogpost brought forward both smiles and tears. I have a question concerning emotional neglect. You were writing: ” These eight included three types of abuse — sexual, verbal and physical. And five types of family dysfunction — a parent who’s mentally ill or alcoholic, a mother who’s a domestic violence victim, a family member who’s been incarcerated, a loss of a parent through divorce or abandonment. He later added emotional and physical neglect, for a total of 10 types of adverse childhood experiences, or ACEs.” I am interested in reading some of the work that includes EN. I understand that this work underline the point that the stress from different kinds of adversive experiences work together, but it would be really interesting to also have a look at the effect from different types of trauma, especially EN as this is a type of ACE that is often overlooked. Kind regards, Serina Vorland, Norway.

    Like

    Reply

  276. So not only did I get to survive a horrid childhood (ACE score = 5) but now I get to have negative effects on my ability to get and keep health care?

    Like

    Reply

  278. Reblogged this on Overexcitable and commented:
    This is epigenetics. This is how nature and nurture interact. This is how vulnerable children are. And this is why adults need to start stepping up!

    Like

    Reply

  287. I appreciate the study for many reasons but primary among them is the title- it does not label the person but the experience … Too often label keep people feeling like it is their identity rather than a condition resulting from ideas or experiences. Now people like me can continue undoing the impressions of these experiences to free ourselves from their effects!

    Like

    Reply

  291. […] FN2  ACE Study original 1998 publication: Felitti VJ, Anda RF, et.al.,  Relationship of childhood abuse and household dysfunction to many of the leading causes of death in adults: The Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 1998;14: 245–258. ACE Study official Centers for Disease Control website Detailed article on the ACE Study by Jane Stevens […]

    Like

    Reply

  298. Terribly important. BUT: To put is briefly:
    1. Does abuse cause addiction?
    Or
    2. Does addiction cause abuse?
    I think the answer is ‘yes’ to both questions. The second one may be more important. The cascade of ACEs passes from generation to generation, along with any hereditary component. The genetic risk for alcoholism is almost always going to be accompanied by the ‘second-hand smoke’ effect in the family and society.

    Like

    Reply

  305. I shared this wonderful article on facebook, and a lot of my friends have also. One person unfriended me over it, saying that “Trying to trigger people who have been raped and molested is extremely unacceptable. ” So i guess maybe this article needs to be labeled with a trigger warning . ..

    Like

    Reply

  306. I don’t buy any of it. As someone who has had a terrible problem with depression, I can say unequivocally that I never experienced any sexual encounters as a child. And I still managed to make myself crazy. What made me get better? Discovering that I create my mental disturbance. No one else can do it. No situation or circumstance can make me feel any particular way. I make myself feel what I feel by what I tell myself about my situation. And I remain a typical human being. That’s the hard and fast truth. People survived Auschwitz with no permanence mental incapacity. And they were in the majority. People are born into a life of luxury and drive themselves crazy. Our mental world is what we create. That’s it!

    Like

    Reply

    • Hi, Mick. Thanks for your comment. If you look at the “Got Your ACE Score?” tab in the navigation bar, you’ll see that sexual abuse is one of 10 types of trauma. You can suffer severe depression without having been sexually abused. Certainly, when a person is an adult, it is that person who is in charge of changing, and many people have, with help. However, the science is very clear that when you’re a child, your brain’s structure and functioning can be changed by the events occurring around you.

      Like

      Reply

      • I did not know I was sexually abused until I had a hypnotherapy session… I was telling the therapist this story (that with my adult mind was critiquing as complete BS!) about having my head shoved down into a toilet. Well, about two weeks later I suddenly realized that I no longer had the ‘habit’ of never flushing the toilet until the door was open. Did that my entire life, and just put it down to a bad toilet-training experience. If I had not had that spontaneous remission of an ingrained practice, I never would have believed the situation had happened, even though I was there! Must have buried that one deep. Never had a problem with toilets again. Thanks for the great work!

        Like

    • Well, Mick… If *you* say that a huge, well designed, very conclusive public health study is incorrect, it must be true!

      You’re an N of one. Your personal experience certainly has validity, but you should refrain from applying it to everyone else in the world.

      The take-away from the study is not that people cannot recover from a traumatic childhood. It’s that we’ll save money and lives if we prevent the trauma to start with, and if we address the needs of the many, many adults who haven’t been so fortunate as you in their own healing processes.

      Like

      Reply

    • Hi Mick,
      It’s great to take responsibility for our lives as adults. However, much trauma occurs before we are adults, some of it pre-verbally. This repeated trauma creates well-worn “pathways” in the brain, and these dysfunctional pathways are used by us as adults until we can create new, healthy pathways. The dysfunctional pathways made “sense” when we were young trying to cope/survive. They no longer serve us in adulthood. Unfortunately, they are pernicious, and not always easily identified.

      Like

      Reply

  309. This is facinating. I wonder about onset and prevalence of eating disorders into adulthood, which is on the other end of the spectrum – the notion of wanting to disappear, or even be seen/noticed after losing weight, and the relationship with parental/family neglect.

    Like

    Reply

  310. […] on childhood abuse and it's frighteningly lucid connection with substance abuse is a must read: The Adverse Childhood Experiences Study — the largest, most important public health study you … it starts off on the link to obesity, then into addiction. in answer to the supplements I'm doing […]

    Like

    Reply

  315. I have just read this article after it was sent to me by someone who knew I worked with women with weight issues brought about by emotional reasons. I use a number of techniques with my clients to work at the source issues of their weight, but predominantly EFT. Like Dr. Robert Anda, I was moved to tears when I realised the extent of the suffering by so many. And I was especially touched by Ella Herman’s story, as it matches so many of my clients.

    Thank you for your detailed reporting of such an important topic.

    Like

    Reply

    • I am a survivor of this type of abuse. I definitely rank above 5 on the scale. I’ve been in a healing period for over 31 years.

      In 1997 I did a report on “Healing from Childhood Sexual Abuse” for a class. Using then current numbers, I estimated that 97million Americans had experienced some type of intimate violation prior to their 18th birthday. The population of the 1990 census was 274 mln. This means that fully one third of the population of our country fell into this category. I was enraged to realize this.

      I am now convinced that this is the single biggest health problem faced by Americans today. Let me know if I can be of service.

      Best regards,
      Sarah M.

      Like

      Reply

      • Hi, Sarah — Thanks for your comment. I’m sorry that you suffered so much abuse. Yes, it’s stunning how many people are affected by this. I’d encourage you to join ACEsConnection, a community of practice social network whose members are people who are implementing — or thinking about implementing — ACE, trauma-informed and resilience-building practices.
        Cheers, Jane

        Like

  316. I am so grateful for your research. I can relate. I have a ACE score of 5, based on this information. I had fibromyalgia, depression, migraines and PTSD for years. I met Dr. David Mickel, and with his treatment, Mickel Therapy, got well. I have been a Mickel Therapist for years now, and the one thing I noticed with all of my clients is, they were not able to be themselves, many times because of abuse, but their fight or flight was often on..Dr. Mickel realized this caused a physical condition called “Hypothalmitis”. Basically, fight or flight stuck on. The treatment is a talking therapy, one which they are taught to recognize how they feel, and act on it. We believe that, in other words, these conditions were caused by “mishandling of Negative emotions. As a Mickel Therapist, this is what we teach them..your studies are all the same as this, just in different words.
    I will give a copy of this article to all I treat, as it may assist them in returning to good health.
    Thank you for all you did and are doing for people like me..

    Sincerely,
    Kim Cormier, LPN, Mickel Therapist, Author

    Like

    Reply

  325. Reblogged this on Recovery in Oklahoma and commented:
    This is critical information to those of us who work in the behavioral health field. Not only do we need to understand the implications, our clients need help understanding how the events of their childhood may have contributed to the problems they experience as adult. Hopefully, through that understanding they can find a way to overcome and thrive in adulthood.

    Like

    Reply

  330. thank you so much for your writing about this and promoting efforts to address the need for healing the wounds of generations of human beings. i am heartened by bringing light to these areas of our collective darkness.

    Like

    Reply

Leave a comment